TY Newest Additions
Just Listed
All Beanie Babies
Christmas
Recently Restocked
Hallmark Ornaments
Christmas TY
All Barbies
All Coins
Swarovski Crystal
Precious Moments
Stocking Stuffers
Shop Christmas Treasures

Maria B. Says:

"I would highly recommend this seller. Very fast shipping. Good communication"

Just Listed - Hallmark Ornaments

Need These!

Katie L. Says

"Love this online store! A great small business that is very responsive, fast shipping & quality products!"
Department 56

Shop the Latest TY Treasures

See More
Teeny Tys - Zack the White TigerTeeny Tys - Zack the White Tiger
TY Teeny Tys - Zack the White Tiger
$30.97
Only 2 left
Ty Beanie Boos - Frost the Arctic Fox, Glitter EyesTy Beanie Boos - Frost the Arctic Fox, Glitter Eyes
TY Ty Beanie Boos - Frost the Arctic Fox, Glitter Eyes
$170.97
Only 3 left
Beanie Ballz- Monaco the Tiger, Solid EyesBeanie Ballz- Monaco the Tiger, Solid Eyes
TY Beanie Ballz- Monaco the Tiger, Solid Eyes
$15.97
Only 1 left
Ty Beanie Baby (Plastic Key Clip) - Mrs. Prickly the Pink HedgehogTy Beanie Baby (Plastic Key Clip) - Mrs. Prickly the Pink Hedgehog
TY Ty Beanie Baby (Plastic Key Clip) - Mrs. Prickly the Pink Hedgehog
$26.97
Only 4 left
Ty Pinkys (Key Clip) - Rosa the Pink Guinea PigTy Pinkys (Key Clip) - Rosa the Pink Guinea Pig
TY Ty Pinkys (Key Clip) - Rosa the Pink Guinea Pig
$14.97
Only 1 left
Teeny Tys - Mimi the Blue OwlTeeny Tys - Mimi the Blue Owl
TY Teeny Tys - Mimi the Blue Owl
$12.97
Only 2 left
Ty Beanie Boos - Joey the Pink Fox, (10"), Glitter Eyes, Claire's ExclusiveTy Beanie Boos - Joey the Pink Fox, (10"), Glitter Eyes, Claire's Exclusive
TY Ty Beanie Boos - Joey the Pink Fox, (10"), Glitter Eyes, Claire's Exclusive
$74.97
Only 1 left
Ty Beanie Boos - Specks the Elephant, Medium (9"), Glitter EyesTy Beanie Boos - Specks the Elephant, Medium (9"), Glitter Eyes
TY Ty Beanie Boos - Specks the Elephant, Medium (9"), Glitter Eyes
$29.97
Only 1 left

Shop Curated Gift Collections

View all
Gifts for 90's Kids
Gifts for Disney Lovers
Gifts for Boys
Gifts for Moms
Gifts for Girls
Gifts for Grandmas
Gifts for Grandpas
Gifts for Dads

Shop Hallmark Keepsake Ornaments

View all
Hallmark Ornament: 1994 Cheers to You! | QX5796Hallmark Ornament: 1994 Cheers to You! | QX5796
Hallmark Hallmark Ornament: 1994 Cheers to You! | QX5796
From $17.00
Only 1 left
Choose options
Hallmark Ornament: 1992 Norman Rockwell Art | QX2224Hallmark Ornament: 1992 Norman Rockwell Art | QX2224
Hallmark Hallmark Ornament: 1992 Norman Rockwell Art | QX2224
From $7.97
Only 2 left
Choose options
Hallmark Ornament: 1992 Tobin Fraley Carousel
Hallmark Hallmark Ornament: 1992 Tobin Fraley Carousel
From $9.00
Only 4 left
Choose options
Hallmark Ornament: 1994 Going to Town | QK1166Hallmark Ornament: 1994 Going to Town | QK1166
Hallmark Hallmark Ornament: 1994 Going to Town | QK1166
From $7.97
Only 3 left
Choose options
Hallmark Ornament: 1992 Comet & Cupid | XPR9737Hallmark Ornament: 1992 Comet & Cupid | XPR9737
Hallmark Hallmark Ornament: 1992 Comet & Cupid | XPR9737
From $12.97
Only 2 left
Choose options
Hallmark Ornament: 1994 Mistletoe Surprise | QX5996Hallmark Ornament: 1994 Mistletoe Surprise | QX5996
Hallmark Hallmark Ornament: 1994 Mistletoe Surprise | QX5996
From $7.97
Only 2 left
Choose options
Hallmark Ornament: 1999 Easter Egg Surprise | QEO8377Hallmark Ornament: 1999 Easter Egg Surprise | QEO8377
Hallmark Hallmark Ornament: 1999 Easter Egg Surprise | QEO8377
From $7.97
Only 3 left
Choose options
Hallmark Ornament: 2007 Peppermint Pup | WD4095Hallmark Ornament: 2007 Peppermint Pup | WD4095
Hallmark Hallmark Ornament: 2007 Peppermint Pup | WD4095
From $7.97
In Stock
Choose options
Hallmark Abearnathy - #3, The Bearingers Keepsake Ornament 1993 XPR9747Hallmark Abearnathy - #3, The Bearingers Keepsake Ornament 1993 XPR9747
Hallmark Hallmark Abearnathy - #3, The Bearingers Keepsake Ornament 1993 XPR9747
From $7.97
In Stock
Choose options
Hallmark Ornament: 2002 Winter Wonderland | QX8086Hallmark Ornament: 2002 Winter Wonderland | QX8086
Hallmark Hallmark Ornament: 2002 Winter Wonderland | QX8086
From $11.97
Only 1 left
Choose options
Hallmark Ornament: 2006 Union Pacific Veranda Turbine Locomotive | QX2323 | LionelHallmark Ornament: 2006 Union Pacific Veranda Turbine Locomotive | QX2323 | Lionel
Hallmark Hallmark Ornament: 2006 Union Pacific Veranda Turbine Locomotive | QX2323 | Lionel
From $16.97
Only 1 left
Choose options
Hallmark Ornament: 1998 Princess Leia | QXI4026 | Star WarsHallmark Ornament: 1998 Princess Leia | QXI4026 | Star Wars
Hallmark Hallmark Ornament: 1998 Princess Leia | QXI4026 | Star Wars
From $16.97
Only 1 left
Choose options

Recently Restocked

View all
Precious Moments: C0017 A Special Toast to Precious Moments | Collectors ClubPrecious Moments: C0017 A Special Toast to Precious Moments | Collectors Club
Precious Moments Precious Moments: C0017 A Special Toast to Precious Moments | Collectors Club
$9.00
Only 5 left
Hallmark Ornament: 1992 Genius at Work | QX5371Hallmark Ornament: 1992 Genius at Work | QX5371
Hallmark Hallmark Ornament: 1992 Genius at Work | QX5371
From $8.00
Only 2 left
Choose options
Ty Beanie Boos - Safari the Giraffe (Solid Feet 2012 Tags), Large (16"), Solid Eyes, Justice StoresTy Beanie Boos - Safari the Giraffe (Solid Feet 2012 Tags), Large (16"), Solid Eyes, Justice Stores
TY Ty Beanie Boos - Safari the Giraffe (Solid Feet 2012 Tags), Large (16"), Solid Eyes, Justice Stores
$47.97
Only 1 left
Ty Beanie Baby - Kayla the Kangaroo, 30th AnniversaryTy Beanie Baby - Kayla the Kangaroo, 30th Anniversary
TY Ty Beanie Baby - Kayla the Kangaroo, 30th Anniversary
$12.97
In Stock
Swarovski Crystal: 015151 Petrol Wagon
Swarovski Swarovski Crystal: 015151 Petrol Wagon
From $33.00
Only 1 left
Choose options
Ty Beanie Baby: Mystic the Unicorn - 2009 version
TY Ty Beanie Baby: Mystic the Unicorn - 2009 version
$27.97
Only 2 left
Hallmark Ornament: 1996 Nolan Ryan | QXI5711Hallmark Ornament: 1996 Nolan Ryan | QXI5711
Hallmark Hallmark Ornament: 1996 Nolan Ryan | QXI5711
From $7.97
In Stock
Choose options
Ty Beanie Baby: Lucky the ladybug
TY Ty Beanie Baby: Lucky the ladybug
$9.97
In Stock
Ty Beanie Boos - Gilbert the Pink & Purple Giraffe, Glitter EyesTy Beanie Boos - Gilbert the Pink & Purple Giraffe, Glitter Eyes
TY Ty Beanie Boos - Gilbert the Pink & Purple Giraffe, Glitter Eyes
$13.97
Only 1 left
Department 56 | Ox Sled | Please ReadDepartment 56 | Ox Sled | Please Read
Department 56 Department 56 | Ox Sled | Please Read
$10.00
Only 1 left
Hallmark Ornament: 1996 Caspar Myrrh | QK1184Hallmark Ornament: 1996 Caspar Myrrh | QK1184
Hallmark Hallmark Ornament: 1996 Caspar Myrrh | QK1184
From $7.97
Only 5 left
Choose options
Ty Beanie Baby: Springer the Bear
TY Ty Beanie Baby: Springer the Bear
$15.97
Only 1 left

What Our Customers Are Saying

"Treasure Keeper is my go to source for unique & vintage collectible items."

-- Connie B. Oct 2026

"Even more beautiful in person, this was my first purchase and it was a great experience. It came rather quickly impact safe and securely with no issues whatsoever."

-- Suzon L. August 2026

"Excellent condition exactly as shown and very fast. Would definitely order from here again. Thank you!"

-- John D. Oct 2026

Read More Reviews

Explore Department 56

View all
Department 56: 54526 Tour the Village
Department 56 Department 56: 54526 Tour the Village
From $18.99
Only 1 left
Choose options
Department 56: 57509 Crown & Cricket Inn
Department 56 Department 56: 57509 Crown & Cricket Inn
From $71.00
Only 3 left
Choose options
Department 56: 59544 Ichabod Crane's Cottage
Department 56 Department 56: 59544 Ichabod Crane's Cottage
From $41.00
In Stock
Choose options
Department 56: 58345 Mulberrie Court
Department 56 Department 56: 58345 Mulberrie Court
From $119.00
Only 1 left
Choose options
Department 56: 55506 Peggotty's Seaside Cottage
Department 56 Department 56: 55506 Peggotty's Seaside Cottage
From $41.00
Only 5 left
Choose options
Department 56: 52614 Snowy Evergreens Large
Department 56 Department 56: 52614 Snowy Evergreens Large
From $32.00
Only 1 left
Choose options
Department 56: 56014 Elf Bunkhouse
Department 56 Department 56: 56014 Elf Bunkhouse
From $44.00
In Stock
Choose options
Department 56: 55506 Mr. Wickfield Solicitor
Department 56 Department 56: 55506 Mr. Wickfield Solicitor
From $35.00
Only 2 left
Choose options
Department 56: 56711 Check This Out
Department 56 Department 56: 56711 Check This Out
From $20.99
Only 1 left
Choose options
Department 56 Village Market, Snow Village, 50440Department 56 Village Market, Snow Village, 50440
Department 56 Department 56 Village Market, Snow Village, 50440
From $61.97
Only 1 left
Choose options
Department 56: 58462 Fine Asian Antiques - Set of 2
Department 56 Department 56: 58462 Fine Asian Antiques - Set of 2
From $29.00
Only 2 left
Choose options
Department 56: 58302 East Indies Trading Co.
Department 56 Department 56: 58302 East Indies Trading Co.
From $56.00
Only 1 left
Choose options

Shop By Brand

FREE Shipping!

All orders over $40 ship for FREE

SHOP NOW

Thousands of 5 Star Reviews

Two decades of experience + Our passion for service = A great buying experience for you!

VIEW OUR REVIEWS

Proud to Be a Family Business

Serving Families like yours since 1999

READ OUR STORY

Recently viewed