TY Newest Additions
Just Listed
All Beanie Babies
Recently Restocked
Hallmark Ornaments
Halloween
Welcome Fall
Lladró
Precious Moments
Swarovski Crystal
Warehouse Finds
Hallmark Ornaments
Shop Christmas Treasures

Maria B. Says:

"I would highly recommend this seller. Very fast shipping. Good communication"

Just Listed - Hallmark Ornaments

Need These!

Katie L. Says

"Love this online store! A great small business that is very responsive, fast shipping & quality products!"
Recent Restocks

Shop the Latest TY Treasures

See More
Ty Beanie Boos - Austin the Owl, Glitter EyesTy Beanie Boos - Austin the Owl, Glitter Eyes
TY Ty Beanie Boos - Austin the Owl, Glitter Eyes
$14.97
Only 3 left
Ty Beanie Boos - Bugsy the Red Ladybug, Medium (9"), Glitter EyesTy Beanie Boos - Bugsy the Red Ladybug, Medium (9"), Glitter Eyes
TY Ty Beanie Boos - Bugsy the Red Ladybug, Medium (9"), Glitter Eyes
$14.97
Only 1 left
Ty Beanie Boos - Cherie the Unicorn, Glitter EyesTy Beanie Boos - Cherie the Unicorn, Glitter Eyes
TY Ty Beanie Boos - Cherie the Unicorn, Glitter Eyes
$11.97
Only 3 left
Ty Beanie Ballz (Plastic Key Clip) - Spongebob SquarepantsTy Beanie Ballz (Plastic Key Clip) - Spongebob Squarepants
TY Ty Beanie Ballz (Plastic Key Clip) - Spongebob Squarepants
$16.97
Only 1 left
Ty Beanie Boos - Izzy the Ladybug, Glitter EyesTy Beanie Boos - Izzy the Ladybug, Glitter Eyes
TY Ty Beanie Boos - Izzy the Ladybug, Glitter Eyes
$14.97
Only 3 left
Ty Beanie Baby (Plastic Key Clip) - Mrs. Prickly the Pink HedgehogTy Beanie Baby (Plastic Key Clip) - Mrs. Prickly the Pink Hedgehog
TY Ty Beanie Baby (Plastic Key Clip) - Mrs. Prickly the Pink Hedgehog
$26.97
Only 4 left
Ty Halloweenie Beanies - Scream the Witch Jack O' LanternTy Halloweenie Beanies - Scream the Witch Jack O' Lantern
TY Ty Halloweenie Beanies - Scream the Witch Jack O' Lantern
$7.97
Only 1 left
Ty Halloweenie Beanies - Phantom the Halloween Ghost BearTy Halloweenie Beanies - Phantom the Halloween Ghost Bear
TY Ty Halloweenie Beanies - Phantom the Halloween Ghost Bear
$9.97
In Stock

Shop Curated Gift Collections

View all
Gifts for 90's Kids
Gifts for Disney Lovers
Gifts for Boys
Gifts for Moms
Gifts for Girls
Gifts for Grandmas
Gifts for Grandpas
Gifts for Dads
Collection's name

Recently Restocked

View all
Department 56: 54854 Holly Brothers Garage
Department 56 Department 56: 54854 Holly Brothers Garage
From $74.00
Only 1 left
Choose options
Department 56: 56371 Holiday Deliveries
Department 56 Department 56: 56371 Holiday Deliveries
From $26.00
Only 2 left
Choose options
Swarovski Figurine: 173742 Town HallSwarovski Figurine: 173742 Town Hall
Swarovski Swarovski Figurine: 173742 Town Hall
From $115.00
Only 2 left
Choose options
Hallmark Ornament: 1997 The Clauses on Vacation | QX6112 | 1st in SeriesHallmark Ornament: 1997 The Clauses on Vacation | QX6112 | 1st in Series
Hallmark Hallmark Ornament: 1997 The Clauses on Vacation | QX6112 | 1st in Series
From $7.97
In Stock
Choose options
Angel of Joy Barbie - 19633Angel of Joy Barbie - 19633
Mattel Angel of Joy Barbie - 19633
From $31.00
Only 2 left
Choose options
Hallmark Ornament: 1984 Graditude | QX3444Hallmark Ornament: 1984 Graditude | QX3444
Hallmark Hallmark Ornament: 1984 Graditude | QX3444
From $7.00
Only 1 left
Choose options
Hallmark Jovie - Elf Keepsake Ornament 2025 QXI8425Hallmark Jovie - Elf Keepsake Ornament 2025 QXI8425
Hallmark Hallmark Jovie - Elf Keepsake Ornament 2025 QXI8425
From $19.00
Only 1 left
Choose options
Ty Beanie Baby: I Love Florida the BearTy Beanie Baby: I Love Florida the Bear
TY Ty Beanie Baby: I Love Florida the Bear
$8.97
Only 1 left
1999-2008 S Proof State Quarter Set Run CN-Clad in Lenses No Boxes or COAs 50 Coins1999-2008 S Proof State Quarter Set Run CN-Clad in Lenses No Boxes or COAs 50 Coins
U.S. Mint 1999-2008 S Proof State Quarter Set Run CN-Clad in Lenses No Boxes or COAs 50 Coins
$89.00
Only 3 left
Precious Moments Ornament: 523704 May Your Christmas Be a Happy Home | DatedPrecious Moments Ornament: 523704 May Your Christmas Be a Happy Home | Dated
Precious Moments Precious Moments Ornament: 523704 May Your Christmas Be a Happy Home | Dated
$8.00
Only 1 left
Swarovski Crystal: 236718 Blue Siamese Fighting FishSwarovski Crystal: 236718 Blue Siamese Fighting Fish
Swarovski Swarovski Crystal: 236718 Blue Siamese Fighting Fish
From $121.00
Only 3 left
Choose options
Hallmark Ornament: 1991 Greatest Story | QX4129Hallmark Ornament: 1991 Greatest Story | QX4129
Hallmark Hallmark Ornament: 1991 Greatest Story | QX4129
From $7.97
Only 3 left
Choose options

What Our Customers Are Saying

"Treasure Keeper is my go to source for unique & vintage collectible items."

-- Connie B. Oct 2026

"Even more beautiful in person, this was my first purchase and it was a great experience. It came rather quickly impact safe and securely with no issues whatsoever."

-- Suzon L. August 2026

"Excellent condition exactly as shown and very fast. Would definitely order from here again. Thank you!"

-- John D. Oct 2026

Read More Reviews

Shop Figurines

View all
Precious Moments: 531375 Llamas | Noah's Ark - Two by TwoPrecious Moments: 531375 Llamas | Noah's Ark - Two by Two
Precious Moments Precious Moments: 531375 Llamas | Noah's Ark - Two by Two
$16.00
Only 1 left
Precious Moments: b0001 Our Club Can't Be Beat | Birthday Club Charter MemberPrecious Moments: b0001 Our Club Can't Be Beat | Birthday Club Charter Member
Precious Moments Precious Moments: b0001 Our Club Can't Be Beat | Birthday Club Charter Member
$6.00
In Stock
Swarovski Crystal: 162886 Field MouseSwarovski Crystal: 162886 Field Mouse
Swarovski Swarovski Crystal: 162886 Field Mouse
From $33.00
Only 1 left
Choose options
Precious Moments: E-5204 The Hand that Rocks the Future | Mozart's LullabyPrecious Moments: E-5204 The Hand that Rocks the Future | Mozart's Lullaby
Precious Moments Precious Moments: E-5204 The Hand that Rocks the Future | Mozart's Lullaby
$17.00
Only 1 left
Swarovski Figurine: 955440 Champion Gorilla CubSwarovski Figurine: 955440 Champion Gorilla Cub
Swarovski Swarovski Figurine: 955440 Champion Gorilla Cub
From $127.00
Only 3 left
Choose options
Lladró Figurine: Nao 369 Duck Looking Back
Nao by Lladró Lladró Figurine: Nao 369 Duck Looking Back
From $44.00
Only 2 left
Choose options
Swarovski Figurine: 898130 Community Title Plaque
Swarovski Swarovski Figurine: 898130 Community Title Plaque
From $18.00
Only 3 left
Choose options
Swarovski Figurine: 234710 Kris BearSwarovski Figurine: 234710 Kris Bear
Swarovski Swarovski Figurine: 234710 Kris Bear
From $57.00
Only 1 left
Choose options
Precious Moments: E-2841 Baby's First Picture | Baby's First SeriesPrecious Moments: E-2841 Baby's First Picture | Baby's First Series
Precious Moments Precious Moments: E-2841 Baby's First Picture | Baby's First Series
$19.00
Only 1 left
Hummel Figurine: Let's Sing - 110/IHummel Figurine: Let's Sing - 110/I
Hummel Hummel Figurine: Let's Sing - 110/I
From $39.00
Only 3 left
Choose options
WDCC Doc - Cheerful Leader | 1028560 | Disney's Snow WhiteWDCC Doc - Cheerful Leader | 1028560 | Disney's Snow White
Disney WDCC Doc - Cheerful Leader | 1028560 | Disney's Snow White
From $55.00
Only 1 left
Choose options
Precious Moments: 128686 Another Year And More Grey HaresPrecious Moments: 128686 Another Year And More Grey Hares
Precious Moments Precious Moments: 128686 Another Year And More Grey Hares
$7.50
Only 1 left

Shop By Brand

FREE Shipping!

All orders over $40 ship for FREE

SHOP NOW

Thousands of 5 Star Reviews

Two decades of experience + Our passion for service = A great buying experience for you!

VIEW OUR REVIEWS

Proud to Be a Family Business

Serving Families like yours since 1999

READ OUR STORY

Shop Designer Hand Bags

View all
Coach Purse: Chalk L.E. Whiplash Saddle Leather Crossbody BagCoach Purse: Chalk L.E. Whiplash Saddle Leather Crossbody Bag
Coach Coach Purse: Chalk L.E. Whiplash Saddle Leather Crossbody Bag
$425.00
Only 1 left
Coach Purse: Edie Colorblock Leather Shoulder BagCoach Purse: Edie Colorblock Leather Shoulder Bag
Coach Coach Purse: Edie Colorblock Leather Shoulder Bag
$215.00
Only 1 left
Aimee Kestenberg Purse: White Quilted Leather Crossbody BagAimee Kestenberg Purse: White Quilted Leather Crossbody Bag
Aimee Kestenberg Aimee Kestenberg Purse: White Quilted Leather Crossbody Bag
$45.00
Only 1 left
Coach Wallet: F49609 Red Madison Gathered Twist WalletCoach Wallet: F49609 Red Madison Gathered Twist Wallet
Coach Coach Wallet: F49609 Red Madison Gathered Twist Wallet
$100.00
Only 1 left
Dooney & Bourke Purse: Rasberry Flap Wristlet HandbagDooney & Bourke Purse: Rasberry Flap Wristlet Handbag
Dooney & Bourke Dooney & Bourke Purse: Rasberry Flap Wristlet Handbag
$35.00
Only 1 left
Coach Purse: Brown Leather Combo Wallet with Zip Back BagCoach Purse: Brown Leather Combo Wallet with Zip Back Bag
Coach Coach Purse: Brown Leather Combo Wallet with Zip Back Bag
$95.00
Only 1 left
Coach Purse: Madison 19180 Scarf Print Sequin Shoulder BagCoach Purse: Madison 19180 Scarf Print Sequin Shoulder Bag
Coach Coach Purse: Madison 19180 Scarf Print Sequin Shoulder Bag
$75.00
Only 1 left
OH by Joy Gryson Purse: Green Olivia Harris Crossbody BagOH by Joy Gryson Purse: Green Olivia Harris Crossbody Bag
OH by Joy Gryson OH by Joy Gryson Purse: Green Olivia Harris Crossbody Bag
$45.00
Only 1 left
Michael Kors Purse: Hamilton Beford Blue Leather Shoulder BagMichael Kors Purse: Hamilton Beford Blue Leather Shoulder Bag
Michael Kors Michael Kors Purse: Hamilton Beford Blue Leather Shoulder Bag
$200.00
Only 1 left
Judith Leiber Purse: Black Suede Rhinestone Clutch Shoulder BagJudith Leiber Purse: Black Suede Rhinestone Clutch Shoulder Bag
Judith Leiber Judith Leiber Purse: Black Suede Rhinestone Clutch Shoulder Bag
$325.00
Only 1 left
Dooney & Bourke Purse: Red Leather Vinyl Crossbody BagDooney & Bourke Purse: Red Leather Vinyl Crossbody Bag
Dooney & Bourke Dooney & Bourke Purse: Red Leather Vinyl Crossbody Bag
$55.00
Only 1 left
Barbie: 30th Anniversary Tote BagBarbie: 30th Anniversary Tote Bag
Barbie Barbie: 30th Anniversary Tote Bag
$26.18
Only 1 left

Recently viewed